top of page

10TOESDown Press

Law & Liberty Desk

THE NORTH STAR      THE WHITE ROSE      MILK      FOSTA‑SESTA      ON THE DOCKET      FROM THE WIRE      THE 50‑STATE TRACKER      ABOUT THE DESK

The White Rose

“We will not be silent.”

Wir schweigen nicht — after Sophie Scholl

The desk for sex-worker rights and adult-content law — age-verification mandates, platform bans, FOSTA-SESTA, and the fight over who may speak about sex.

Records & Consent

FTC and Utah Extract $5 Million and Consent Rules From Pornhub's Owner

Aylo, formerly MindGeek, agreed to pay $5 million and to overhaul how it verifies the consent and identity of people appearing in uploaded content.

The White Rose  •  By The White Rose Desk  •  Sex Work & Speech Desk  •  September 3, 2025  •  5 min read  •  United States (FTC) / Utah / District of Utah

FTC and Utah Extract $5 Million and Consent Rules From Pornhub's Owner

The Federal Trade Commission headquarters. A 2025 order requires Pornhub's owner to verify performer consent and identity. — AI-generated illustration

The Federal Trade Commission and Utah's Division of Consumer Protection announced on September 3, 2025 a settlement requiring Aylo, the company formerly known as MindGeek that operates Pornhub, to pay $5 million and to adopt sweeping consent- and identity-verification controls. Regulators charged that the company deceived users by failing to keep child sexual abuse material and nonconsensual content off its sites despite promising it was strictly prohibited.

The complaint, filed in the District of Utah, alleged that over years the platforms hosted tens of thousands of images and videos depicting child sexual abuse material and nonconsensual material even as the company represented that such content was banned. The government framed the conduct as unfair and deceptive under consumer-protection law.

Under the stipulated order, Aylo must pay $5 million to Utah and implement a program to verify the age, identity and consent of every person depicted in content uploaded to its sites, retain documentation supporting those checks, and remove material that fails them. The order also requires the company to detect and block reuploads of previously removed abusive content and to monitor its moderation systems on an ongoing basis.

For the adult-performer beat, the settlement matters because it turns consent and identity documentation into an enforceable regulatory obligation rather than a voluntary policy, echoing the record-keeping logic of federal law while operating through consumer-protection authority. Officials called it a landmark action against an adult-content operator; industry lawyers say it signals that platforms distributing user-uploaded adult material will face records-and-consent scrutiny from state and federal regulators alike.

$5M

Payment to Utah

2025-09-03

Settlement announced

Pull quote

— Source

Video caption

How the case moved

2025-09-03

FTC and Utah announce complaint and stipulated order against Aylo

2025-09-08

Settlement documents finalized

✓  Fact check

Claim

“The FTC criminally prosecuted Pornhub's owner and shut the site down.”

Reality

This was a civil consumer-protection settlement in the District of Utah requiring a $5 million payment and consent-verification reforms, not a criminal case or shutdown.

§

Legal References

Bluebook citation · cases, statutes & the record

Primary legal authority cited in this report. Links go to the public record where one exists.

[1]

FTC & Utah Div. of Consumer Protection v. Aylo (Stipulated Order), D. Utah (Sept. 3, 2025); FTC Act enforcement ¶ source

U.S. District Court, District of Utah 2025

Academic References

ABA / law-review style · secondary scholarship

Secondary scholarship that informs the analysis.

[1]

Reference text

#FTC

#Aylo

#MindGeek

#Pornhub

#ConsentVerification

#Records

#Utah

#NonconsensualContent

Author bio

Source: TechCrunch

More from The White Rose

Kicker

Related headline

Oct 7, 2026

NurFüsse · 10TOESDown

The Law & Liberty Desk — three mastheads, one dispatch.

The North Star · The White Rose · Milk — nurfusse.com

bottom of page